Updated: September 2026

Meet the American heritage apple that once ruled the mid-Atlantic. The Stayman Winesap is one of the great late-19th-century American varieties — deeply flavored, wine-touched, spicy, and firm enough to last through winter in a cold cellar. If you love complex, bold, old-fashioned apple flavor, the Stayman is your apple. It's what Grandpa's apple pie tasted like.

Order fresh Stayman apples direct from our orchard.

A Brief History of the Stayman Apple

The Stayman was discovered in 1866 by Dr. Joseph Stayman of Leavenworth, Kansas — a seedling of the older Winesap variety. Dr. Stayman propagated and named it after himself, and it was formally introduced in 1895. For decades in the early 20th century, Stayman was one of the most planted apples in the mid-Atlantic states — especially Virginia, West Virginia, and Kentucky. Modern cold storage varieties have pushed it out of grocery stores, but Stayman lovers keep the flame alive.

Did You Know?

  • Discovered in 1866. A seedling of the older Winesap apple.
  • Named after its discoverer. Dr. Joseph Stayman of Kansas.
  • Once the dominant mid-Atlantic apple. Especially popular in Virginia and West Virginia.
  • Spicy, wine-touched flavor. Complex, bold, unlike modern breeding-lab varieties.
  • Firm, dense flesh. Holds shape beautifully in pies and roasts.
  • Late-season harvest. Ready mid- to late October, often after first frost.
  • Excellent keeper. 3–5 months refrigerated.

Best Uses

  • Baking. The Stayman's true genius — the definitive old-fashioned pie apple.
  • Cider. The wine-like complexity elevates any cider blend.
  • Applesauce. Bright, complex flavor with real depth.
  • Fresh eating. If you love a bold, spicy, complex apple, Stayman is unmatched.
  • Apple butter. One of the traditional apples for slow-simmered apple butter.
  • Roasted with pork or duck. The wine notes caramelize magnificently.
  • Cheese boards. Pairs beautifully with sharp cheddar, aged Gouda, and cured meats.

Storage & Shelf Life

Stayman stores well — 3–5 months refrigerated at 30–35°F. The flavor actually improves in the first few weeks of storage as the sugars develop. Crisper drawer in a plastic bag with holes poked in it, away from bananas and tomatoes.

Stayman Recipes to Try

Similar Apples You Might Love

  • Winesap — the Stayman's parent variety, similarly spicy and complex.
  • Northern Spy — another bold, complex, long-storing heritage apple.
  • GoldRush — modern equivalent for complex flavor and long storage.
  • Rome — another classic American baking apple.

Ready to Try One?

Order fresh Stayman apples from our orchard and taste an apple that ruled America for a century.

Questions? Reach us at [email protected].